Steak On Blackstone Vs Grill: Decoding the Best Technique

Steak on Blackstone vs Grill is the subject of a spirited debate among food enthusiasts and chefs alike. Each brings its unique allure: Blackstone griddles offer a flat, heat-efficient cooking surface while traditional grills captivate with an open flame for that signature smoky flavor. Understanding temperature control, cook times, and the characteristics of your chosen cut of meat is key to achieving a juicy, flavor-packed steak on either surface.

Navigating the choice between gas grills, charcoal grills, or a stainless-steel Blackstone griddle involves knowing each tool’s strengths and weaknesses. Grills, such as the Weber grill, infuse a unique smoky taste and delightful char, whereas Blackstone griddles seal in juices effectively, leading to a moist, tender steak. Your choice of steak cut – be it prime rib, filet mignon, or New York strip – also influences the cooking process and end result.

steak on blackstone vs grill

In this article, Soup’s Sports Grill delves into the intricacies of cooking steaks on a Blackstone griddle vs a traditional grill. We’ll dissect the roles of grates and burners, share tips for the perfect sear, and introduce tantalizing recipes for both cooking methods. Prepare to embark on an immersive journey into the world of outdoor cooking and elevate your steak mastery.

Steak On Blackstone Vs Grill

The decision between cooking steak on a Blackstone griddle versus a traditional grill often boils down to the specific cooking experience and end result you seek. Both cooking surfaces offer distinct features and can yield different outcomes when it comes to taste, texture, and the overall steak-cooking experience. Understanding the advantages and drawbacks of each method will help you make a well-informed choice.

Steak on Blackstone Griddle

When discussing Blackstone griddles, we refer to flat-top cooking surfaces known for their ability to distribute heat evenly and maintain a consistent temperature. They have become a beloved tool among home cooks and professional chefs, particularly for steak preparation.

Advantages of Blackstone Griddle

Blackstone griddles have become increasingly popular over the past few years, with many home cooks and professional chefs alike incorporating them into their kitchens. These flat-top cooking surfaces provide a variety of benefits that make them ideal for a range of dishes, from breakfast foods like pancakes and eggs to lunch and dinner favorites like hamburgers and stir-fries.

  • Versatility: Boldly, the Blackstone griddle excels in its ability to cook a wide variety of foods. Unlike a traditional grill, the flat surface of a Blackstone griddle allows for the even heating and cooking of smaller or more delicate foods that would otherwise fall through grill grates, such as diced vegetables, shrimp, or pancakes. The griddle’s surface is perfect for searing meats, toasting buns, and even cooking pizzas, adding a whole new dimension to outdoor cooking.
  • Consistent and Even Heating: Another significant advantage of Blackstone griddles is their ability to provide consistent and even heating across the entire cooking surface. The griddles are designed with heat zones, which can be individually controlled, allowing you to cook different foods at different temperatures simultaneously. This feature offers tremendous convenience when preparing a diverse array of dishes.
  • Easy to Clean: The Blackstone griddle boasts ease of cleaning as one of its major selling points. The flat-top surface means there are no nooks and crannies where food and grease can hide, as is the case with traditional grills. After cooking, all it takes is a scrape down with a griddle scraper and a wipe with a cloth to have your griddle looking as good as new.
  • Durability: A key attribute of the Blackstone griddle is its exceptional durability. Made from heavy, industrial-strength materials, these griddles are built to withstand repeated use and exposure to high temperatures, ensuring they can stand up to the rigors of both home and commercial kitchens. With proper care and maintenance, a Blackstone griddle can last for years, providing excellent value for money.

blackstone grill vs gas grill

In conclusion, the Blackstone griddle’s versatility, consistent and even heating, easy cleaning, and durability make it a top choice for those looking to elevate their outdoor cooking experience. These features not only simplify the cooking process but also ensure that food is prepared to perfection each time.

Drawbacks of Blackstone Griddle

While Blackstone griddles are a fantastic cooking tool, they are not without their potential drawbacks. Like any piece of equipment, they come with certain considerations and potential downsides that may influence your decision to purchase one. These could include the initial setup, size and weight, maintenance requirements, and fuel type.

  • Initial Setup: The first potential drawback is the initial setup of the Blackstone griddle. Depending on the specific model, these griddles can be fairly complex and time-consuming to assemble. Additionally, they often require a proper seasoning process before the first use, which could be intimidating for first-time users.
  • Size and Weight: The size and weight of Blackstone griddles can also be seen as a disadvantage. They tend to be quite large and heavy, which could be a problem for those with smaller outdoor spaces or for those who would like a portable option for camping or tailgating. Their size also makes them more difficult to store during the off-season.
  • Maintenance: Regular maintenance is another consideration with Blackstone griddles. These griddles require regular cleaning and reseasoning to prevent rust and maintain their non-stick cooking surface. This can be a more time-consuming process compared to maintaining a traditional grill.
  • Fuel Type: Lastly, the use of propane as the fuel source for Blackstone griddles might be a concern for some users. The dependence on propane tanks means ensuring you have a sufficient supply on hand, especially for longer cooking sessions. Additionally, propane tanks add an extra cost and need regular refilling or replacement.

Drawbacks of Blackstone Griddle

In conclusion, while Blackstone griddles are celebrated for their cooking versatility and performance, their initial setup, size, weight, maintenance, and reliance on propane fuel are factors that potential users should consider. Weighing these potential drawbacks against the benefits will ensure you make an informed decision that suits your specific cooking needs and lifestyle.

Steak on Traditional Grill

Grilling is an age-old method of cooking steak and for good reason. Traditional grills offer a unique set of advantages that have won over many steak lovers over the years.

Advantages of Traditional Grill

Traditional grills have been a staple in many households and commercial kitchens for years. Offering a unique flavor profile and an enjoyable cooking experience, they provide a range of advantages that set them apart from other cooking appliances, such as Blackstone griddles or ovens. These benefits include imparting distinct flavors, providing ease of use, portability, and having different fuel options.

  • Distinct Flavors: Foremost, traditional grills stand out due to their ability to impart distinct flavors to the food. The direct heat and smoke from charcoal or wood pellet grills, in particular, provide a smoky flavor that is hard to replicate with other types of cooking appliances, including flat-top griddles. Gas grills, while less smoky, also offer a unique grilled flavor. This is a major draw for many grill enthusiasts who enjoy this characteristic taste in their food.
  • Ease of Use: Traditional grills, especially gas grills, are often praised for their ease of use. Unlike griddles that require initial seasoning and regular reseasoning, grills can be used with little prep work. They often feature straightforward controls, allowing users to adjust heat levels easily, making them suitable for both novice and experienced grillers.
  • Portability: The advantage of portability is often associated with traditional grills. Many models, especially kettle grills and portable gas grills, are designed for easy transport and storage. This makes them ideal for activities like camping, tailgating, or any outdoor event where you want to cook and enjoy food on the go.
  • Variety of Fuel Options: Traditional grills offer a variety of fuel options, providing flexibility to the user. Charcoal grills, gas grills, and electric grills all offer different benefits and flavors. Charcoal grills are known for their smoky flavor, gas grills for their convenience and ease of use, and electric grills for their efficiency and indoor use capability.

can a blackstone replace a grill

In conclusion, traditional grills offer several advantages that make them a popular choice for many. The distinct flavors, ease of use, portability, and variety of fuel options make them a versatile and enjoyable means of cooking. However, as with any appliance, potential users should consider these benefits in the context of their individual needs and preferences.

Drawbacks of Traditional Grill

While traditional grills have long been celebrated for their unique culinary capabilities and versatility, it’s important to note that they also come with their own set of potential drawbacks. Key considerations for those contemplating a traditional grill include factors like cleaning difficulties, potential health risks, temperature control, and fuel costs.

  • Cleaning Difficulties: One common concern with traditional grills is the difficulty of cleaning. Unlike flat-top griddles, grills have grates that food can stick to, making them harder to clean. Residue and grease can build up on these grates over time, requiring regular scrubbing and maintenance. Charcoal grills also accumulate ash that needs to be disposed of regularly.
  • Potential Health Risks: The potential health risks associated with grilling are another drawback. Cooking food, particularly meat, at high temperatures over an open flame can lead to the formation of certain harmful compounds, like polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and heterocyclic amines (HCAs). These substances have been linked to an increased risk of cancer. Therefore, careful consideration and safe grilling practices are necessary to mitigate these risks.
  • Temperature Control: Temperature control can be more challenging on a traditional grill compared to other cooking appliances. This is particularly true for charcoal grills, where adjusting the heat involves carefully managing the distribution of charcoal and airflow. Gas grills provide more control, but they still don’t offer the same level of precision as kitchen stovetops or griddles with multiple heat zones.
  • Fuel Costs: The cost of fuel is another factor to consider. Gas grills require propane or natural gas, both of which can be costly depending on usage. Charcoal grills, on the other hand, require charcoal or briquettes which, while typically less expensive than gas, still represent an ongoing cost and require regular replenishment.

is a blackstone better than a grill

In conclusion, while traditional grills offer unique flavor profiles and the joy of outdoor cooking, they also come with potential drawbacks like cleaning difficulties, potential health risks, challenges in temperature control, and fuel costs. Weighing these drawbacks against the benefits will help potential users make an informed decision that aligns with their cooking preferences and lifestyle.

Additionally, traditional grills pose a risk of flare-ups from fat dripping onto the open flames. These sudden bursts of flame can quickly over-char your steak if not controlled promptly.

Comparative Table: Blackstone Griddle vs. Traditional Grill

When it comes to outdoor cooking, the decision between a Blackstone Griddle and a traditional grill often rests on the specific needs and preferences of the user. Each comes with unique benefits and potential downsides spanning factors like versatility, even heating, ease of cleaning, portability, fuel options, setup and maintenance, flavor profile, temperature control, health risks, and cost. The following table provides a more detailed comparative analysis of the two:

Blackstone Griddle Traditional Grill
Versatility ✓ Can cook a wide variety of foods from pancakes to steaks due to its flat cooking surface. X More suitable for meats and larger vegetables but can struggle with smaller items.
Even Heating ✓ Offers consistent and even heating with separate heat zones for precise control. X Heat consistency is variable and dependent on the fuel source and grill management skills.
Ease of Cleaning ✓ Flat surface is easy to scrape and wipe clean. X Grates can be difficult to clean, and charcoal grills also accumulate ash.
Portability X Generally large and heavy, which is not ideal for transport. ✓ Many models are designed with portability in mind, making them suitable for outings.
Fuel Options X Typically uses propane as the sole fuel source. ✓ Can use charcoal, gas, or electricity depending on the model.
Setup and Maintenance X Requires an initial setup and regular reseasoning to maintain the surface. X While the setup is generally easier, grates need regular cleaning, and charcoal grills require ash disposal.
Flavor Profile X Can sear foods well but lacks the smoky flavor associated with grills. ✓ Can impart a unique, smoky flavor, particularly when using charcoal or wood fuels.
Temperature Control ✓ Individual heat zones allow for precise temperature control. X Gas grills offer reasonable control, but managing heat on charcoal grills requires more skill.
Health Risks ✓ Lower potential for the formation of harmful compounds like PAHs and HCAs due to the absence of open flames. X Cooking over open flames can lead to the formation of harmful compounds, especially when food is charred.
Cost X is Generally more expensive initially, but the cost of propane can be economical over time. X Initial cost for basic models is lower, but the ongoing fuel costs can add up over time.

is a griddle better than a grill

As you can see, both the Blackstone Griddle and the traditional grill offer unique benefits and potential downsides. The choice between the two will largely depend on your specific needs and cooking preferences.

Other Tips for Cooking Steak on Blackstone Vs Grill

Regardless of the cooking method you choose, there are universal tips that apply when cooking steak on either a Blackstone griddle or a traditional grill. Here are a few pointers to elevate your steak cooking experience.

Quality of Meat

The cut and quality of the steak play a critical role in determining the taste and texture of your meal. Opting for a high-quality steak with good marbling (the intramuscular fat) ensures that your steak will be flavorful and tender. Marbling melts during cooking, adding to the steak’s succulence and taste. Thus, spending a little more on a prime cut of meat can significantly enhance your dining experience.


Proper preparation sets the stage for a perfect steak. Allowing the steak to reach room temperature before cooking promotes even heating throughout the steak, preventing a cold center. Seasoning your steak at least an hour before cooking gives the spices sufficient time to penetrate the meat, leading to a flavorful steak. The salt in the seasoning also helps to tenderize the steak, improving its texture and taste.

cooking steak on a blackstone griddle

Temperature Control

Controlling the heat is a key aspect of cooking steak. On both a Blackstone griddle and a traditional grill, maintaining a consistent temperature ensures that your steak cooks evenly. A meat thermometer is an indispensable tool for this. It allows you to monitor the internal temperature of the steak, ensuring it reaches your desired level of doneness. This can help avoid an overcooked, dry steak or an undercooked, too-rare one.


The resting period after cooking is just as crucial as the cooking process itself. When you let the steak rest for a few minutes after cooking, the juices that have been pushed to the center of the steak during cooking get a chance to redistribute. This results in a juicy steak with flavors that are evenly distributed throughout.


Keeping your cooking surface clean is essential for several reasons. For one, it prevents the buildup of old food residues, which could impart unwanted flavors to your steak. Additionally, regular cleaning extends the life of your griddle or grill, keeping it in optimal working condition. It also reduces the risk of flare-ups caused by fat and grease buildup, especially relevant when using a traditional grill.

does blackstone make a grill

Whether you’re a fan of the even heating and versatility of a Blackstone griddle or prefer the high temperatures and smoky flavors of a traditional grill, these tips can help enhance your steak cooking skills. With patience, practice, and perhaps a few trials and errors, you’ll be well on your way to mastering the art of steak cooking on your preferred surface.

FAQs about Steak On Blackstone Vs Grill

Is steak better on the grill or griddle?

Steaks can be excellently cooked on both grills and griddles, but many people prefer grills for their unique smoky flavor. When you cook steak on a grill, the open flames help to create a distinct, rich taste that is difficult to replicate on a griddle. Nonetheless, a griddle offers its own advantages, such as more even heating and a juicier result, making it a perfectly viable option for steak preparation. Ultimately, the choice between a grill and a griddle comes down to personal flavor preferences and the cooking experience you seek.


Are Blackstone grills good for steaks?

Absolutely, Blackstone griddles are excellent for cooking steaks. They provide a spacious, even-heating cooking surface that can accommodate not only your steak but also various side dishes. The griddle’s ability to sustain a consistent temperature makes it ideal for achieving a perfect sear on your steak, sealing in the juices, and enhancing the flavor. Whether you’re preparing a solo meal or hosting a backyard barbecue, a Blackstone griddle can help you cook your steak to perfection while also allowing for the simultaneous preparation of complementary dishes.

Why Blackstone instead of Grill?

Choosing a Blackstone griddle over a traditional grill provides several distinct advantages. The expansive cooking area of a griddle allows you to prepare multiple dishes at once, promoting efficiency in your cooking process. Blackstone griddles, in particular, are highly regarded in the market for their quality and durability.

They are constructed with premium materials, such as a solid steel griddle top, ensuring their longevity and consistent performance. Therefore, a Blackstone griddle can be an excellent choice if you’re seeking versatility, time efficiency, and robustness in your outdoor cooking equipment.

How can I introduce a smoky flavor when cooking steak on a Blackstone griddle?

While the absence of open flames makes it slightly challenging, there are methods to introduce smoky flavors on a griddle. You can use smoking pellets or a smoker box with wood chips to add a hint of smoke to your steak on a griddle.

Can I use a different brand of griddle if I don’t own a Blackstone?

Yes, certainly. Any griddle should offer a comparable cooking experience. However, the quality of the outcome may vary based on the specific griddle’s design and materials.

What precautions can I take to prevent flare-ups when cooking steak on a traditional grill?

Maintaining your grill with regular cleaning can significantly reduce the risk of flare-ups. Additionally, keep a spray bottle of water nearby to put out any sudden flames. Trimming excess fat off your steak before grilling can also minimize flare-ups.

Is there a substantial price difference between a Blackstone griddle and a traditional grill?

Prices for both Blackstone griddles and traditional grills vary, depending on their size and features. Generally, the cost of these two methods of outdoor cooking is quite comparable.

Conclusion for Steak On Blackstone Vs Grill

Steak On Blackstone Vs Grill: the debate is as exciting as the cooking itself. Each method has its unique attributes, appealing to different tastes and cooking styles. A Blackstone griddle offers an even heat distribution and ample cooking space, which is perfect for searing steaks while preparing side dishes simultaneously. Meanwhile, a traditional grill provides that unique smoky flavor and appealing grill marks on your steaks, adding to the visual and gustatory delight.

Choosing between a Blackstone griddle and a traditional grill ultimately depends on your personal preference and the kind of cooking experience you desire. By understanding the advantages and drawbacks of each, you can make an informed decision that suits your needs, preferences, and culinary aspirations.

Remember, the joy of cooking lies not only in the result but also in the process. So, whether you’re a seasoned cook or a beginner, don’t be afraid to experiment with both methods and discover which one brings you the most satisfaction.

If you found this article helpful and informative, please share it with your friends, neighbors, market housewives, food enthusiasts, and others. Sharing knowledge is an excellent way to inspire and encourage others on their culinary journey. Happy cooking!

Share now
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x